Here are Jeff’s comments. I will quote a portion about Rich Lusk:

Although Rich’s response is very gracious, it is nonetheless quite devastating. His response is long, but the whole thing is quite edifying and helpful. Rich as been marginalized, even demonized for many reasons, one of which is his lack of acceptable graduate theological academic credentials, but as far as I’m concerned writings like this indicate that Rich should be teaching systematics in one of our top seminaries. This is a topsy-turvy age.

Indeed. And the phenomenon is not limited to Rich. Peter Leithart is teaching at a college. What’s up with that? Seminaries should be actively recruiting him. And Ralph Smith’s two books on the covenant are more than worthy of the respect accorded anything found in the Westminster Theological Journal.